This is an algorithmic puzzle where you just have to turn some coins.
Problem statement
You are inside a dark room, sitting at a table. The table in front of you is covered with coins, which you can feel, but you can't really see what their face up is. You are told, however, that exactly 20 of those coins have heads facing up and all the others have tails facing up.
Your task is to divide the coins in two groups, such that both piles have the exact same number of coins with their heads face up.
The only things you can really do are
- move coins around (to put them in one group or the other); and
- turn coins upside down.
Recall that the room is so dark, you can't really tell which face each coin has up, nor can you feel it with your touch.
Give it some thought and send me your solution!
If you need any clarification whatsoever, feel free to ask in the comment section below.
This problem was shared by @TodiLiju, who comments these “problem” posts from time to time.
Solvers
Congratulations to the ones that solved this problem correctly and, in particular, to
- Attila K., Hungary.
for sending in a correct solution.
Solution
Because there are so many things that we don't know about the coins, when we start, and because of how little we control (we can't look at a coin and see which face is up) there are not many things that we can try to do. The only thing we know for sure is that there are \(20\) coins that have the “heads” face up.
This “\(20\)” is the only thing we have/know, so why not make a group of \(20\) coins, and leave the rest of the coins in their own group? Assume \(n\) is the total amount of coins on the table, and say that the group of \(20\) coins has \(k\) coins that have their “heads” face up.
Here is a summary of the situation:
| Coins in group | Heads | Tails | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| \(20\) | \(k\) | \(20 - k\) | ||
| \(n - 20\) | \(20 - k\) | \(n - 40 + k\) |
What we need, now, is to have the same number of coins with their “heads” face up in both groups. Currently, the group with \(20\) coins has \(k\) coins like that and the group with \(n - 20\) coins has \(20 - k\) coins like that. However, if we flip all the coins in the group of \(20\) coins, then all coins would swap their face up, which means we would get a total of \(20 - k\) coins with their “heads” face up, matching the other group.
In conclusion, what we need to do is:
- grab a total of \(20\) coins at random;
- flip all of them.
Don't forget to subscribe to the newsletter to get bi-weekly problems sent straight to your inbox and to add your reaction below.
Espero que tenhas aprendido algo novo! Se sim, considera seguir as pisadas dos leitores que me pagaram uma fatia de pizza 🍕. O teu pequeno contributo ajuda-me a manter este projeto grátis e livre de anúncios aborrecidos.
